Echo CS-4010 vs Craftsman S1600

Echo CS-4010

Echo / Gas

Echo CS-4010

40cc class

~$349

4.1/5 Home Depot

See it at Echo
Craftsman S1600

Craftsman / Gas

Craftsman S1600

40cc class

~$199

3.7/5 Lowe's

See it at Craftsman

The Craftsman S1600 costs about $150 less; the Craftsman S1600 has more engine (42cc); the Echo CS-4010 swings a longer bar (18 in).

SpecEcho CS-4010Craftsman S1600
Approx. price~$349with 18" bar and chain~$199with 16" bar and chain
Engine class40cc classby displacement40cc classby displacement
Power typeGasGas
Use caseHomeownerHomeowner
Engine41.6 cc42 cc
Rated power1.9 kW—
Bar length18 in16 in
Single-pass cutabout 16 inabout 14 in
Bar range18 in16 in
Chain3/8" low-profile pitch / .050" gauge (91PX)3/8" low-kickback pitch / .050" gauge
Weight9.4 lbpowerhead only (dry)12.2 lbwith bar and chain
Warranty5-year consumer / 1-year commercial2-year limited

Tinted cells mark the better figure on that row alone: more engine, longer bar, lighter, cheaper. A lighter weight is only a win on the same basis.

What owners like and complain about

Echo CS-4010

  • 13% more power and 0.7 lb lighter than the CS-400 it replaced
  • 9.4 lb powerhead makes an 18-inch-bar saw feel like a limbing saw
  • i-30 starting system noticeably cuts pull-cord effort
  • 5-year consumer warranty backed by Home Depot availability and Echo dealers
  • 1.9 kW is genuinely enough for 14-16 inch hardwood bucking
  • Side-access chain tensioner and translucent fuel tank are practical touches
  • 4.1-star Home Depot rating reflects real starting-consistency complaints from a minority of owners
  • Several longtime Echo owners say the air filter design is a downgrade from the CS-400
  • 3/8" low-profile chain limits aggressive full-chisel upgrade options
  • Assembly and starting instructions frustrate first-time gas-saw buyers
  • No 20-inch bar option — this is firmly a homeowner saw

Craftsman S1600

  • Full-crank 42cc engine rather than the half-crank common under $200
  • 12.2 lb ready to cut is light for a 42cc saw
  • 3-point anti-vibration and a self-activated chain brake are not givens at this price
  • Tool-free access to spark plug and air filter makes seasonal maintenance quick
  • Sold at Lowe's nationwide, so returns are easy even if service is not
  • 3.7-star average across 660 Lowe's reviews is the weakest in the value gas tier
  • Plastic starter housing is the part owners report failing
  • Low-kickback chain cuts slowly until replaced
  • 2-year warranty with no dealer network behind it
  • Carburetion complaints cluster after storage — fuel discipline is not optional
Echo CS-4010 in fullCraftsman S1600 in fullMore matchups